Has Obama been swindled?

UPDATED:
 
This article popped up in the news today.
 


Regarding Charity, there are many glaring inaccuracies.

The article states that: "Damage from Katrina closed Charity Hospital "

The article states: "The Federal Emergency Management Agency estimated that repairing the structure would cost $23.9 million, but the university countered that it would cost $257 million. This led the university to propose building a new facility rather than renovating the old one."

 
In fact, LSU wanted $476 million dollars because, they claimed, Charity was more than 51% damaged.
 
Charity was NOT more than 51% damaged.

FEMA was correct in not offering the half billion LSU wanted for the lower midcity hospital. The hospital was cleaned out and ready to open in September of 2005 as evidenced by photos on our website and testimony from medical and military staff who were in the hospital at the time and cleaned it out. 

Roberta Gratz' does a terrific job outlining this injustice in her Nation article - Why Was New Orleans's Charity Hospital Allowed to Die?

Charity Hospital appeared trashed sometime after that to make it look 51% damaged in the photos and videos LSU used to support their claim.

Mary Landrieu set up the arbitration panel that potentially defrauded the federal government out of half a billion dollars by disallowing witnesses for State FEMA from testifying at the hearing. Flights to fly in witnesses were deamed too costly and offers from advocates to reopen Charity Hospital to fly them in were refused.


Tax payers and the Federal Government spent this enormous amount of money so that LSU could demolish an historic neighborhood in the name of building a public hospital that was to restore full services and programs that Big Charity offered.
Pre-arbitration, LSU had all the money they needed in State Capital outlay dollars and the original offer from FEMA to fully gut and reopen the original 1939 art deco historic building.

Today, the State can not show that the new UMC academic medical building, now under construction, has a commitment for full funding. The hospital has been leased to the Louisiana Children's Medical Center corporation [LCMC] who will operate it while LSU will create private/public partnerships with other private hospitals and institutions to house their patients.  Residents will follow the patients for training.  The LCMC will become sole member of the supposedly public UMC Board.  

This calls into question why the new UMC academic medical center is being built at all and whether or not it's new purpose - that could ostensibly mean it will house a private hospital - is permitted under the eminent domain laws used to take hundreds of properties, many of them historic homes that were rebuild by their loving occupants after Katrina with road home money.

Will  these injustices go forever unnoticed by the Federal Government and tax payers who may have been robbed?

There are so many questions.


 

Jindal killed the sacred cow‏

On Monday December 10, 2012 Bobby Jindal effectively put a fork in the sacred cow - known as the Charity Hospital System - that developed over a more than 270 year period.

Jindal, long  a proponent of privatizing everything within view, took advantage of a recent federal reduction in Medicaid dollars to the State, as an excuse to unnecessarily turbocharge his mission.  The term is opportunistic.

Hmmm, taking advantage of a disaster as an opportunity to push through politically unpopular policy.  Where have we seen this before?  No one can forget how the State and LSU used Hurricane Katrina as an excuse to shutter the existing building when it was ready to go back into operation three weeks after the storm.

In New Orleans, as of last Monday, Jindal's privatization mission is just steps away from turning our single payer safety-net hospital over to a Louisiana Children's Medical Center [LCMC] - a non-profit corporation- effectively transforming a sacred cow into a cash cow to be milked by a non-transparent and non-accountable entity as stated in an MOU signed by:  "LSU Board of Supervisors, Louisiana Children’s Medical Center and others relating to the future operation of the Interim Louisiana Hospital and, upon its completion, the new University Medical Center in New Orleans."

The MOU specifically states:

Jindal's rubber-stampers, otherwise known as the LSU Board of Supervisors, will bless this MOU [and two other Charity System hospitals] at a special meeting December 14, 2012 at 10:00 am.

Another interesting paragraph in the MOU gives us over here at SaveCharityHospital.com pause.

Is this a sign that Mr. Jindal will be obligated to accept the Federal Medicaid Reimbursement?  If so, will the real Mr. Jindal please stand up?

Meanwhile... back at the UMC construction site.... with patients and residents farmed out to other private providers and institutions, what the heck is that suburban monstrosity going up in Lower MidCity for? 

Perhaps the best answer to date lies with LSU Health Science Center Chancellor Larry Hollier - the only Charity Hospital official not fired or demoted by the Governor; or ....retired.  WWLTV reported on June 10th, 2011 in the following interview:

""They're missing the point," said Larry Hollier, MD, chancellor of the LSU Health Science Center. "This is not trying to build a community hospital. This is trying to build a destination hospital like UAB in Birmingham, like MD Anderson in Houston.""

A destination Hospital that will be leased to a private corporation with no accountability to report on their promise that any surpluses resulting from this Private Public Partnership will be invested back into the UMC Hospital.

Is BioDistrict New Orleans - ostensibly a boundary line with a little more than $12 000 dollars in it's bank account - encompassing 1500 acres of mostly MidCity, Gert Town and Zion City - ready to compete with Houston and Birmingham?  More than one article suggests that New Orleans may have already missed that opportunity boat.

Tight State Funds Hamper Development of New Orleans

Perhaps more clarity surrounding the plethora of questions circulating in the mediasphere will be answered this Thursday, December 13 when all eyes will be on what may be one of the last public meetings of the UMCMC board if this MOU is passed as it is currently written.

Agenda pending.

Details:
3PM
LSU Health Sciences CenterLions Clinic Building,
2020 Gravier Street, New Orleans, Louisiana
Isadore Cohn Student Learning Center,
6th Floor.

Follow us on twitter
@charityhospital

 

Flying Without A Safety Net Means People Will Die‏

LSU's Decision to cut the charity out of the 7 Charity Hospitals in Southern Louisiana, instigated at the behest of the Governor to find a way to absorb Federal cuts to medicaid spending in Louisiana, speaks volumes about LSU's administrators disrespect for human life.  The Governor, for what appears to be political reasons, chose not to accept the Federal medicaid reinbursement that was enacted as part of the Affordable Care Act.  This will hundreds of thousands uninsured, with nowhere to go.

Such a shame!  LSU physicians have a proven track record of offering some of the world's best and most advanced heathcare to all of their patients in Louisiana - regardless of class, race or economic situation.  Indeed, many insured people have communicated to SaveCharityHospital.com that they would go nowhere else.  Doctors have offered their services with compassion and concern to all who enter any of the 10 State-run Charity Hospitals.

Medical students have traditionally come to New Orleans to study at Charity Hospital due to the challenging conditions, a complicated genetic mix and to participate in the most advanced medical scientific research in the country.  It seems that LSU is now mostly concerned with capitalizing on students to increase profit margins while eliminating services and programs for patients. Would potential students choose to study at LSU if they had to do their residencies at private hospitals under public/private partnerships with other hospitals. That question needs to be asked.  The national agency that accredits graduate medical education programs is pressing LSU officials for information on their plans to revamp physician training programs.

Compassion does not seem to imbibe to administrators and some legislators that dance to the Machiavellian beat of the Governor's drum.

That the decision to cut funding for the thousands of indigent, working poor and uninsured was implemented without first creating a system to absorb such patients means that many in Louisiana could very well die.
  This is not hyperbole.  Yet this was predictable.

The decision to privatize the Charity system - a single payer system thats biggest flaw was a lack of transparency and accountability - was made well before Katrina.

Brad Ott, is an expert in heathcare and, in particular, the Charity Hospital system and has revived Advocates for Louisiana Public Healthcare [ALPH] in the wake of the latest cuts.   His thesis is titled "The Closure of New Orleans' Charity Hospital After Hurricane Katrina: A Case of Disaster Capitalism"

There is a lot of evidence that LSU planned on closing Charity before Katrina.  See the part of his thesis  (after or about page 60) that deals with that hypothesis):

Ott points out that there are options to closing funding gaps without eviscerating charity care from the LSU system. 
The funding options include redirecting funds currently in the private schemes Bayou Health and the Louisiana Behavioral Health Partnership to public safety net LSU and community hospitals and clinics: and reallocation of DSH funds from provide providers to LSU and rural hospitals.

An old trick that right-wing conservatives use in order to eliminate government programs - that many people around the world know well - is to:   Intentionally starve the system to create it's collapse and then use it's collapse to show that it doesn't work and we must privatize it.  It seems that the people of Louisiana have fallen prey to this trick.

We are presented with this false choice by Governor Jindal and the LSU board of supervisors.  While the State had already cut the Charity system to the bone then,  because of  a federal $859 Million dollar cut to Louisiana's medicaid program, Governor Bobby Jindal decided to privatize the whole system.

Who wins and who loses under this sort of system?  Without transparency and accountability, what is to stop private insurance companies and/or hospitals from continuing to game the system?  The idea of forking over truckloads of public money to such private institutions before such regulations or partnerships are in place is distressing at best.

If that weren't enough,  at the LSU Health HCE Fall Quarterly Meeting October 16th, 2012, keynote speaker Dr. Opelka, emphasized that heathcare's future is no longer about bricks and mortar. Yet that's all we heard from LSU about why they had to build a Taj-Ma-Hospital in Lower MidCity on top of a now razed historic neighborhood and community. As well, at some point in the near future, New Orleans City Council will meet to turn over of Pershing Place (Nanny Goat Park) - our public park where the doughboy statue stands as a monument to WWI soldiers - to the State to increase land for a hospital that may be 100 beds at best.   Why on earth does the State need MORE land and why on earth would the Mayor and City Council allow it? Will that take more of the street grid? When the I-10 is dismantled -  (as planned) - think of the traffic nightmare.

So what can you do?

 

Sign this petition to the Lousiana Division of Administration & Department of Health and Hospitals to keep Southeast Louisiana Mental Hospital Open

 

 

Taj-Ma-Hospital Construction Motors On. But Why Bother?‏

 LSU's Taj-Ma-Hospital is looking more and more like Taj-Ma-Impossible these days.
 

On Thursday October 4, 2012, the LSU Board of Supervisors met in Baton Rouge to hear Dr. Frank Opelka, the new head of the seven LSU Charity system hospitals in South Louisiana - [who took the place of Dr. Fred Cerise] - roll out yet another baseless plan.

The plan calls for more drastic cuts* to 7 Charity Hospitals across the State coupled with the idea of partnering with private hospitals and institutions in what are known as private/public partnerships to soak up the uninsured and working poor.
How LSU intends for this to happen is still a work in progress yet they are prepared to move forward anyway with a strategy that potentially leaves thousands of uninsured in a situation where they will simply have to find their own way.

These new cuts involve $49 million dollars to LSU's Interim public hospital - the transition facility from the Reverend Avery C. Alexander Charity Hospital to the not yet constructed UMC Academic Medical Center - that will result in the loss of 432 jobs as well as a reduction of beds from 201 to 155.  Clinics will close or reduce their hours. The Times Picayune reported that: "Several clinics at the New Orleans hospital -- women's health, pain management, endocrine, and sickle cell clinics -- will close. The hospital will also close two operating rooms and reduce hours for non-emergency surgeries, likely creating longer waits for such operations."

This is in addition to cutting back or eliminating prisoner care, pediatric and obstetrics care in February of this year.

All of this leaves some of us wondering why bother finishing construction at all? 

After the LSU Board of Supervisors meeting in Baton Rouge, Mr. Robert “Bobby” Yarborough - [Chairman-Elect / Member-at-large and also Governor Jindal's appointee as chairman of the UMC Academic Medical Center Board] - avoided an appearance at the Joint Committee on Health and Welfare where Dr. Frank Opelka and LSU System Interim President William Jenkins - [who took the place of Dr. John Lombardi] - were being grilled by legislators, to attend a UMC Board meeting in New Orleans.  On that agenda was an update on the new hospital construction by Mr. Tom Rish.

The UMC/AMC Board marched up to Baton Rouge last September to give them their "business plan" showing how they could guarantee legislators that they had the $1.1 Billion dollars needed to finish the hospital and would never have to come to the State again to ask for dollars in exchange for the Joint Budget Committee's approval of construction.  It is still not fully clear as to whether or not the State has actual signed contracts with FEMA and the Louisiana Physicians Foundation to make up an approximately $200 million dollar shortfall in construction dollars to finish the Ambulatory Care Building and the second parking garage. Yet the committee voted unanimously to allow LSU and the UMC/AMC Board to go ahead and obliterate Lower Mid-City and all it's historic integrity to build a mini-suburbia in the heart of the New Orleans.

Note: In another meeting at City Hall on Thursday, City Council were asked to hand over Nanny Goat park [also known as Pershing Place] to the State.  With program requirements shrinking, why on earth does LSU want more land?

  To their credit, Councilmembers voted to defer the item for two weeks until the fate of the Dough Boy Statue can be better understood.

It appears that LSU and the Governor now have a new strategy of having legislators rubber-stamp legislation emanating from the Governor's office by simply completely bypassing legislative approval for their plans all together and pushing through an agenda that amounts to full privatization of our healthcare, education and criminal justice systems.


BUT WAIT: Legislators put the brakes on that yesterday during a remarkable session*** that left even the most cynical humbled. Legislators were reluctant to believe that LSU might actually be bringing a REAL business plan to the capital this time and decided that they should be asked to weigh in.

Legislators exposed the fact that LSU have no strategic plan, no economic impact studies, no data to support their claims that private public partnerships are the answer to all our health care problems or on how to go forward with their latest plan.  In addition, Dr. Opelka was rendered speechless by Senator Nevers as he challenged him on who makes the decisions on who will live and who will die in this State.
 
That said, Rep. Jerome "Dee" Richard, an independent [Independent] has called for a special legislative session to discuss how to mitigate cuts to our healthcare system and the closure of S.E. DePaul Mental Hospital. 
 
 
Sign this petition to the Lousiana Division of Administration & Department of Health and Hospitals to keep Southeast Louisiana Mental Hospital Open

***Watch Dr. Frank Opelka, the new head of the seven LSU system hospitals in south Louisiana, rendered speechless as Senator Nevers challenges him to answer who lives and who dies in this state. Beginning at 2:04:55.
(Senator Mills had spoken just before about cuts potentially adding up to more that 34.4 percent if you add in revenue reductions that would make it illegal for LSU to not get legislative approval.
Another stellar moment was when Edwards strongly asserted that LSU should be asking them for money to stop the hemorrhaging until they can find away to deal with Federal cuts coming down the pike.  He was as poignant as Nevers about the fact that  LSU should be placing the emphasis on patient care rather than $$$ or people will die!!! Tune in to that at 3:05:20



*The cuts began when President Obama signed the
Federal transportation Bill into law last July.  Bobby Jindal's refusal to accept medicaid reimbursement cuts means that hundreds of thousands of uninsured in LA will not be able to get medicaid and will be left without a safety net.